Markets Keep Defying the Experts and the News

stock graphic

It is important to have a clear strategy for managing the market’s ever-unfolding uncertainties, staying focused on the right processes, the right tools, and the right mindset to guide you toward your goals. Your investment strategy is one you can apply with confidence through thick and thin.  Investors are otherwise too often moved by volatile markets, veering off-course to chase skyrocketing trends or flee sickening drops, forever second-guessing themselves and “starting over” whenever current events test or tempt their resolve.  Larry Swedroe reminds us about the danger of focusing on media headlines and those who think they can predict the future.

Larry Swedroe is the Director of Research for the BAM ALLIANCE.

This commentary originally appeared September 3, 2014 on

On Aug. 25, the S&P 500 index closed above 2,000 for the first time — finishing at 2,000.24. It had taken the index more than 16 years to double from its first close above 1,000 on Feb. 2, 1998, when it finished at 1,001.27. That 16-year span is more than five times as long as it took for the index to double from its first close above 500 on March 24, 1995, when it finished at 500.97.

On its way to 2,000, the S&P 500 had to endure two major bear markets. It fell from its high of 1,576.74 on Oct. 11, 2007, all the way to its low of 666.79 on March 6, 2009. That means the index has risen more than 1,330 points from its bottom five years ago.

From March 2009 through July 2014, the S&P 500 returned just over 22 percent per year, providing a total return of 195 percent — quite an impressive performance for the period. This year alone, it has defied many so-called experts and risen from 1,848 to 2,000, a price-only gain of more than 8 percent.

Now, imagine you had a clear crystal ball and were able to foresee each and every event that has occurred so far this year, with the exception that you cannot see stock prices.

You might think that would give you a huge advantage in terms of investment decisions. You would know whether the economic and political news was positive or negative. You might even think you could then anticipate how that news would affect the markets.

Now consider all the negative news we have had over the first eight months of 2014. Here’s just a short list:

  • U.S. growth turned negative in the first quarter. Real GDP fell 2.1 percent in the Jan.-March period before recovering in the second quarter.
  • The economies of most other developed markets slowed. Some, like Italy, experienced an outright recession. Others, like Germany, experienced periods of negative growth.
  • The economic growth rate in China, India, Brazil and other major emerging markets has also slowed significantly.
  • Argentina defaulted on its debt.
  • The end of quantitative easing and the start of the Federal Reserve’s “tapering” process — which will be completed in October — is threatening to raise the low interest rates that have helped boost stock prices.
  • The geopolitical situation has been anything but supportive. Russia first invaded and eventually annexed Crimea. Now a widening war is unfolding in Ukraine. We’ve had one crisis after another in the Middle East, any one of which could lead to a disruption in oil supplies. No resolution to the nuclear situation in Iran has materialized, and the civil war in Syria continues. ISIS threatens to disrupt the Middle East’s entire geopolitical situation. Israel and Hamas have waged another war in Gaza. We’ve even seen some Chinese saber rattling in the Pacific.

In addition to all this, investors have been bombarded by regular warnings about the market being overvalued. The so-called Shiller CAPE 10 has been well above its historical average for years, and currently stands at more than 26.

Let’s review some of the dire warnings investors have been hearing.

On Feb. 6, 2013, with the S&P 500 at about 1,500, Grantham Mayo Van Otterloo & Co.’s highly regarded and often quoted investment strategist Jeremy Grantham warned that assets are “brutally overpriced.” And he noted this was true around the globe as well.

John Hussman, founder of the Hussman family of funds, has been offering similar warnings for a long time. Since late 2009, he has been calling for another financial crisis due to bad policy choices from the U.S. government.

His market commentary of Jan. 14, 2013, when the S&P was at about 1,465, stated: “Present overvalued, overbought, overbullish, rising-yield conditions fall within a tiny percentage of market history that is associated with dismal market outcomes, on average. It’s true that we’ve observed extreme conditions since about March 2012 with little resolution aside from short-term declines. But the S&P 500 remains only a few percent from its March 2012 high, and if history is any guide, the extension of these unfavorable conditions is not likely to reduce the depth of the market loss that can be expected to resolve them.”

On Dec. 19, 2013, with the S&P 500 at about 1,800, Marc Faber, publisher of the Gloom, Boom and Doom Report and a frequent guest on CNBC, offered this forecast: “The market will continue to decline from its November high of 1,813.” And on May 8, 2014, with the S&P 500 at about 1,870, Faber warned about a coming crisis bigger than the one we had in 2008.

The stock market has been ignoring such warnings and bad news, defying many so-called experts, for years. Just think about all the bad news the market has studiously ignored since it reached bottom in March 2009. Here’s another brief list of some major problems the market has had to deal with over the last five years.

  • The eurozone debt crisis.
  • The U.S. almost defaulting on its debt and the eventual loss of its AAA credit rating from Standard & Poor’s.
  • A do-nothing Congress that has failed to address America’s long-term budget crisis.
  • The sequestration process, which many warned would have a significant negative impact on the economy.
  • And, of course, all the geopolitical dangers mentioned earlier.

Investors who paid attention to such warnings, and reacted accordingly, have missed out on one of the greatest rallies ever. And we can say the same thing about the bond market, which has defied all forecasts of trouble from rising interest rates. It has ignored experts, such as the “Bond King” Bill Gross, for six years now.

Investors who were scared off by the loud and dire warnings, and who opted to stay with very short maturities, failed to earn the large term premium that has generally existed over the past six years. The yield curve has generally been quite steep. These investors also incurred reinvestment risk because rates not only stayed down, but generally moved lower.

The lesson I hope you take from all this is not only that you should ignore the headlines when making investment decisions, but also that you should ignore all market forecasters. There are simply no good ones. One reason for the inability of anyone to forecast markets well is because, as you have just seen, even a perfectly clear crystal ball that reveals all world events may tell you nothing about where markets are going.

Larry Swedroe is director of research for the BAM ALLIANCE.

Previously, Larry was vice chairman of Prudential Home Mortgage. Larry holds an MBA in finance and investment from NYU, and a bachelor’s degree in finance from Baruch College.

To help inform investors about the evidence-based investing approach, he was among the first authors to publish a book that explained evidence-based investing in layman’s terms — The Only Guide to a Winning Investment Strategy You’ll Ever Need. He has authored six more books:

  • What Wall Street Doesn’t Want You to Know (2001)
  • Rational Investing in Irrational Times (2002)
  • The Successful Investor Today (2003)
  • Wise Investing Made Simple (2007)
  • Wise Investing Made Simpler (2010)
  • The Quest for Alpha (2011)

He also co-authored four books: The Only Guide to a Winning Bond Strategy You’ll Ever Need (2006), The Only Guide to Alternative Investments You’ll Ever Need (2008), The Only Guide You’ll Ever Need for the Right Financial Plan (2010) and Investment Mistakes Even Smart Investors Make and How to Avoid Them (2012). Larry also writes blogs for, Seeking Alpha, and Index Investor Corner on

Share This Post

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join Our Mailing List

Stay up to date on all things Flourish!

Flourish is Ten Years Old!

A decade ago, we embarked on a journey to empower and serve you with values-based financial planning. In 2024, we celebrate our 10th anniversary with immense gratitude for your trust and support. Here’s to many more years of flourishing financially, together!

Skip to content